
I thought to myself, âwhat if I donât do the postgame reaction? What if we all just pretend that this game didnât happen?â
Last week, which feels like a decade ago, I bestowed upon Xavi my most prized of compliments. But while the word I used then was âpulchritudinous,â I think this time Iâll say that, to find out how I feel, you should go to www.thesaurus.com and search the word ârepugnant.â Its synonyms?
Disgusting.
Distasteful.
Odious.
Vile.
Yeah, it was pretty bad. But itâs not even the scoreline Iâm all that upset with; itâs the manner in which the third, fourth, and fifth goals were scored. Itâs not the destination, itâs the journey; itâs not them, itâs us.
Up until the third goal, the Dutch were the less deserving side, but not by a large margin. They had gotten unlucky with some near-chances, thanks to Donyell Malenâs head not being made of pure steel and Crysencio Summerville slipping at the wrong moment. And the first two German goals scored were a combined 0.08 Expected Goalsâtwo very fine shots from distance that happened to be of sublime quality. Yes, the Dutch defense should have done better on both of them. But up until the third goal, it all just felt a little unlucky.
And then the third goal happened. An unnecessary free kick, after a foul from Denzel Dumfries, led to getting beaten in the simplest way possible. Multiple Germans made runs; the scorer, defender Nico Schlotterbeck, was not one of them. He was just standing there, but no one seemed to pick him up. It looked as if he were Joey Veermanâs guy to guard, but Cody Gakpo also should have been quicker to get in front of the ball and clear it. Just a terrible situation to concede.
And then the fourth goal happened.
That goal, to be clear, is completely avoidable and completely unacceptable. With regular left-back JurriĂ«n Timber out of position, Cody Gakpo (while covering as a defender) allows winger Brajan Gruda to just dribble right by him with apparent ease. Tijjani Reijndersâwho I love so much that Iâm sad to criticize himâallows midfielder Florian Wirtz to run past him, and then assumes Van de Ven would pick up Wirtz, which occurs right when Van de Ven charges Gruda to make up for Gakpoâs mistake. The mistake here, if you watch the replay back, is Gakpo realizing too late that he was the sole player in charge of guarding Gruda, and then basically giving up on defending him; that poor defending exposed Reijndersâ own error and sank Dutch stomachs, making a salvaging of the game near-impossible.
I think the fifth goal was a reflection of that reality. The players had given up and were just reacting. But even when facing a humiliating 4-0 scoreline, even when that ignominy is coming in a game where youâre being outplayed by your biggest rivals, even when youâre in the hostile environment that was a near-full Olympiastadionâthat should never happen. As long as a player has the Oranje lion on their chest, the reaction to being down 4-0 should not be one of resignation, but of resilience.
Maybe this was impacted by the captain, Dumfriesâwho had never captained the Dutch from the start of a game beforeâlikely feeling significant responsibility for the first two goals. It was one of his worst games in an orange shirt, ever. Maybe the fourth goal, or this overall lack of leadership on the field, wouldnât have happened if Virgil van Dijk were playing. If Frenkie de Jong cannot play, and neither can the Liverpool defender, maybe the team doesnât have the guy who can act as the necessary glue to keep everyone together, mentally.
If you ask me, it felt like the Dutch just didnât respond well to this game being, well, hard. The resilience wasnât there. I see a lot of people saying that this wouldnât have happened if Van Dijk were on the field; maybe thatâs true. In my post-Greece euphoria, I wrote that itâs possible the team could move beyond him; at no point did I consider the leadership qualities that Virgil âcool-as-you-likeâ van Dijk brought to the starting eleven. Clearly, that was a mistake. Van Dijk and Van Hecke will be a fine duo, assuming both are healthy.
I wouldâve loved to have known how this game wouldâve gone with Frenkie de Jong playing. In addition to the loss of Van Dijk and De Jong, the Dutch felt the absence of striker Brian Brobbey as well; Brobbey, one of the strongest players in the game, would have been better suited to duel the 6â3â Schlotterbeck and the 6â5â Jonathan Tah. When a German high press forces you to heave the ball forward, the 5â10â Malen is unfortunately a poor fit to win those battlesâjust like how Quinten Timber is not well suited to do the job of Frenkie de Jong.
Sir, I served with Frenkie de Jong. I knew Frenkie de Jong. Frenkie de Jong was a friend of mine. Mr. Timber, you're no Frenkie de Jong.
As noted by journalist Bart Frouw, Joey Veerman and Frenkie de Jong exchanged 61 passes in the first half of the game against Greece; Veerman and Timber, in the first half against Germany, exchanged just two.
As you can imagine, Timberâs selection in the starting lineup is one that, retroactively, Iâd change. I would have been interested to see Reijnders in that De Jong role (hasnât it been made clear in previous Dutch games that Reijnders is more than capable there, and in fact prefers it?), and instead put Kluivert in as the attacking midfielder behind Malen. I also would have flipped JurriĂ«n Timber from left-back to his preferred position of right-back, therefore replacing Dumfries in the lineup with left-back Ian Maatsen, giving the wide areas of the field two players adept at resisting the pressânot something that Dumfries is known to do well. It makes you wonder if Xavi was expecting the Germans to play such a press-heavy game; youâd think that this would be no surprise given that itâs new German coach JĂŒrgen Kloppâs signature style.
For this reason, Iâm a little disappointed that Xavi, after the game, chose to place the blame on his players. Itâs not that he said anything close to âitâs their fault,â but he made no admission of failing to prepare his team for the German press. Perhaps he felt he did do that effectively, but the players just did not respond well to it anyway. One of those things weâll never know.
The bar that Xavi has to meet is to play as well against a top nation as Ronald Koeman had the Dutch playing against Spain in the 2025 Nations League quarterfinals, which ended in a thrilling 5-5 aggregate scoreâand which also led me to believe that a World Cup win was possible. That was the last time we saw Oranje match up against some of the worldâs best, but weâll have the opportunity to do so again come March.
Thanks to the margin of this defeat, the Germans actually usurped the Dutch to end the Nations League group in first place. So weâll find out Friday if the Netherlands will match up in the quarterfinals against one of either England, France, or Portugal. Yikes.
I wish I knew more about what allowed the Dutch to be so successful against the future World Cup winners in those 180 minutes last year; maybe Iâd be able to foresee with more certainty whether Xavi will match it.
If Iâm the Spaniard, Iâm spending the next four months doing a Nathan Fielder-style Rehearsal of each day in March that heâll have with his team before the Nations League quarterfinals. The opposition is tough, but this is a winnable trophy. Beat England/France/Portugal over 180 minutes (somehow) and then you are two 90-minute rolls of the dice away from being able to say you won something for the first time since the Ronald Reagan administration. That would be somethingâeven if everyone agrees the Nations League is nothing.
But the circumstances required to believe a win is possible do not include the heaviest defeat since 1959, as this game was, along with it being the heaviest defeat for the Netherlands in a competitive game. The ultimate high against Greece, followed by the ultimate lowâwhat a week.
March is a long way away. Until then, maybe we should just do our best to forget and move on.
Watch highlights from the game below, at your own peril.
PS: I think the most embarrassing thing that could happen to the Dutch soccer federation (the KNVB) would be Mark van Bommel winning the Nations League with Belgium. Weâll never know what the Dutch wouldâve looked like under Van BommelâŠ

